The surprise does not have to include every detail. Let the first reveal be the decision to give them a set. Then invite them to choose the initials they want on a keychain, if that option is available when orders open.

Ask a clear question

“Which letters would you actually put on your own bag?” is easier to answer than asking them to infer a monogram convention. Write the letters back in the exact order for confirmation.

Separate choices from the reveal

If you are using a certificate, keep the color or initials open until the recipient confirms them. Do not submit someone else's information unnecessarily while you are only following a launch.