Book clubs already have the hardest part of a game night: a group that likes to get together. Offer a separate introductory session so nobody feels they have to give up the thing that brought them there.
Protect the regular meeting
Keep the usual book discussion, and choose another date for people interested in American Mahjong. Arrange a teacher or borrow equipment before deciding whether the group needs its own set.
Ask after the trial
If four people want to play again, make a shared schedule. A Mahjoon set can be an option once the group knows it would actually use one.

